Scythe

Kickass megaWAD. Still waiting for the rest of Scythe X to come out, though. :P

Excellent Pace. 4/5

What are you reading dude? Download NOW! 5/5

Finally managed to finish map30. Took me two hours. LOL Christ, I'd love to see a speedrun of this level. Download this if only for map30. all other levels will look tame in comparison.

So mediocre and bland ... hah ha hah ha 5/5 Just kidding! In scythe 2 our mapping hero tried to hard, I think, and lost some of that magical flow and creativity that is widely present in this fantastic megawUUd!.?>

very enjoyable

This was one of the first wads I ever played, and I don't regret playing it. I couldn't beat maps 28 and 30, but I put that down to my lack of skill rather than inadequate level design. I'll beat them one day. For now, 5 stars. - Obsidian

The second episode is better in my opinion, but I still think the levels here are really good.

a true classic

First wad played ever, entirely on hmp. In one word : great !

I never thought I'd say this about any mapset, but Scythe is "cute". Many maps are quick and small and there's something here for everyone: the sneaky type, the crazy type, the speedy type .. and of course it's good for blasting through with a co/op partner. It's almost like a training ground for Doom , where you can work on your skills in a controlled environment. If you pass on this, you'll have missed something great. --5/5

I just played through this set, and while it's admittedly pretty fun, I just don't think it deserves all the hype it gets. The architecture is good in most of the maps and the gameplay steadilly progresses from easy to insanely hard and extreme. But there were lots of maps I didn't like, and only a few that I trully enjoyed. Sorry, short, simple maps with primitive, violent gameplay just aren't to my taste.

This truly is a legendary Doom WAD. Maps 1-20 Aren't very hard, but make for a great evening of solo fun on UV(assuming you are a rather adapt FPS player). Maps 21-30 On the otherhand, are simply stunning to say the least! The maps are all very creative, vary from short and brutal to long and harsh. MAP30 is the hardest DOOM map I have every seen or played, but it remains fun because its possible if you take it slowly! Overall, this is the type of WAD that I would pay money for since it was so well done!

Only thing better than this is av.

Good wad; very challenging levels especially map30! Good design, monster placement. Only criticism is that some levels are too easy and small compared to others. Still great! 4/5.

this is a stupidly cool wad i give 6 stars more than legendary infact it is fucking legendary from the god of doom: oblivionwalker

One of the best wads ever. The only thing I don't like about both Scythes is that the last 10 levels are always fucking stupid. I personally don't care for running around like a maniac firing my bfg, running after cell charges, and loading and saving constantly, only to be cornered by some ridiculous amounts of barons of hell or revenants. Like c'mon. You have to keep it more interesting than that. Level design+detail is always good but the maps past map20 are always a waste of space. Still 5*

Strange I haven't voted yet; though I played it a long time ago. Gameplay here is perfect, excellet nad what not! Quick and interesting, a bit too difficult sometimes, but hey! It's doom! Levels set each in different theme. Superb mustplay for all. -ellmo

Fucking awesome, no doubt about it.

Not bad at all, maybe a bit too small and short, not to mention it's very easy in the beginning, but becomes very hard towards the end. Interesting and fun, I could recommend it for the less experienced average Doom players too, veteran Doomers might find it too easy and boring, except for the last few levels. Level design and textures are OK, music and atmosphere works pretty well, and the whole WAD can be played through in just a few hours. 4/5

Dude, this is the 20th WAD I've played!!! I LOVE THE MUSIC ON LEVEL 26!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ! You were right about the difficulty thing and I died like on level 10, 18, 21, 26, and 30. 1337/5 - Killer11223346

It's great, but I had to give it 4 stars if it wern't for the fact that mep 30 everything slows down! Is that a bug in the wad?

Awesome small, to the point maps, maybe even the best megawad of its kind. And possibly up there with Rebirth for best total surprise megawad release. 5/5

Love this wad. An all time favorite. I hope Scythe 2 comes out soon. Definitely 5 stars out of 5 stars. Especially for Episode 3.

Best WAD ever made!