Knee Deep in Phobos

Very good!

nice gameplay and details, but sniper 109 never seems to mark areas as secrets which is kinda weird. not a fan of the new weapons but the gameplay is pretty good.

The final map was pretty awesome.

Lots of work. Sadly: way too much useless decoration, way too little variations in architecture & texture use, especially the later levels look too much similar to the original ones, and monster placement / gameplay is clearly the last aspect worked on. Overall it was difficult to play this out due to the boredom. Overall there are some remakes which are lightyears better than this one. Still 3* because of the huge effort. BTW map06: yellow door can be opened from the inside, so no need for the yellow key.

5/5, BETTER than KDIZD (But then again, what isn't better than KDIZD?).

5/5, Better then KDiZD, anyone who disagrees can't tell a good wad from their rear ends.

The people calling this crap have no taste. These maps are great. Not epic but still much better then the typical Doom map. ****

Not bad, but nog very good either. ***

Just AWESOME!!! 5/5 - Logan MTM

Too much like KDIZD, but still a great set of maps. ****

IGNORE UDDERDUDE! this Wad is just what the Doom Community needs. okay,so the Plasma gun and BFG are missed,but this experience was like that of the Alphas- Bullets and Shells ONLY. 8 out of 10!!!-DZombie

the Machine gun is FASTER than the Chaingun,and and the Rifle takes a bit of AIMING to work.. you all have been spoiled by DECORATE and Skulltag...Whing little Kids..Grow up and Learn to play like the older Doomers Did.-DZombie

Far from perfect but not bad either, worth trying.

1/5 AWFUL Plain Horrid, so many mistakes. The new weapons are terrible, I see no appeal to using the machine gun or the Dead Aim Burst Machine gun. The levels were decent but at the same time bland. In "E1M9" you could beat the entire level without raising the bars because you can still reach through them. I complete waste of my time to play. On the plus note, I'm at least glad you admitted to have inspiration from KDiZD (its obvious anyways)

A KDiZD wannabe without any of the qualities that made KDiZD rise above its infamous faults to be a great wad. The machine gun has nothing to distinguish it from the chaingun, the level design is unimaginative, and the new grapics are ugly. 2/5 --Woolie

The only thing I used decorate for was the monsters projectils, the new weapons were made with dehacked. also you're wrong the machinegun is SLOWER than the Chaingun. Proof check the dehacked. Chainguns firing duration is 4 where as the machineguns duration is 5. Spoiled by decorate? No. The decorate plays a small role in this wad

This is alright, but it didn't blew me away either. I'll give it 3 stars. Btw, Tormentor is NOT the creator of the new monster sprites! The new Zombie is made by NmN and the base for the burning demon is from Eriance!

Hey, some crazy wad you have there, but you have to be very smart to play trough the levels. For a complex level set it is very good. I especially like the weapon 7 and the fireballs. 5/5.

AWESOME!!! This is by far the best wad ever! Keep up the good work!

I really agree with JJ, I found myself getting lost more than once in these damned mazes known as levels, no offense man, but these levels are too long to just to get in to. 2/5 -Wartorn

Great job. The lighting in the first couple of maps was a bit bright and not very atmospheric but got better in later maps. The secret areas weren't always marked. I felt the difficulty was too easy for UV except for final bosses (some pillars would have helped). Apart from the first map I pretty much enjoyed it. I also thought it recreated the original feel a lot better than KDIZD. So 5* for you.

gameplay is ok, it looks ok, areas are quite good interconnected, but I was missing an individuel touch - something which hits me 3/5

I was very impressed with this. I have seen many fan made doom maps that were shit. This is definitely not one of those! I like the new machine gun, and the zombie.

Excellent!!! 5 stars!

I tried, but I just can't get into this. Alot of these ideas have been done before in KDiZD, and some parts are plain copied from it. There are detailed remakes of familiar rooms, and then alot of extra convoluted areas, tunnels and switch-hunts. It's too easy to get disoriented and lost, and you don't really get an idea of the 3D space around you. Sniper, you're obviously a very talented mapper, but your style is so different from John Romero's, combining his maps and yours just doesn't work. 2/5 -jj