Dark Harvest

WADs like this one are symbolic to the longetivity of this modding scene. No matter what, no matter how long, we'll still be getting those. It's a charming piece, playable but with some odd bumps that stand out. There's one imp stuck on the ledge and one health bottle stuck in a too narrow hole so you can't pick it up. The geometry, at least in maps 01-03, is fully linear and produces only gameplay area without any visual clutter. MAP04 stands in complete contrast to the others and you will see it immediately as you spawn. There's abundance of SSG ammo, armor and to some extent also health, but there's severe lacking of rockets - a common thing among many WADs, probably because rocket boxes give you a small amount of them in comparison to the other ammo boxes. Any player will probably blaze through this map set with no difficulty.

First map was too easy and short, second and third were ok, but easy anyway, and after picking up a ssg third map becomes a cakewalk. Not a lot of monsters variety, if its not a chaingunner waiting in the next room, it will always be an agitating skeleton, also too much armor.  i saw you were trying to create a vanilla feel to the maps with the first three maps, but then you said "Screw this" and made "Tyrant", nice map, but doesn't really belong to this wad, and you clearly put more effort into Tyrant than the rest of the wad. Overall, 4.