LadyMistDragon Posted November 9, 2021 (edited) 10 points to 180 Minutes Por Vivre 9 points to Alien Vendetta 8 points to Ancient Aliens 7 point to Eviternity 6 points to Memento Mori II 5 points to Eternal Doom 4 points to Going Down 3 points to Doom: The Way Id Did 2 points to Memento Mori 1 point to New Doom Community Project Edited November 9, 2021 by LadyMistDragon 4 Quote Share this post Link to post
m8f Posted November 13, 2021 LadyMistDragon, thank you for voting! Tally updated. 0 Quote Share this post Link to post
ReaperAA Posted November 13, 2021 List update time!!!! Added 1000 Lines 3 CP and reshuffled a few older entries 10: Eviternity 9: Heartland 8: Faithless/ Faithless Trilogy 7: 1000 Lines 3 CP 6: Plutonia 2 5: TNT: Revilution 4: Alien Vendetta 3: Valiant 2: Ancient Aliens 1: No Rest For The Living Older list Spoiler 10: Eviternity 9: Faithless/ Faithless Trilogy 8: Heartland 7: TNT: Revilution 6: Alien Vendetta 5: Valiant 4: Ancient Aliens 3: Doom Zero 2: No Rest For The Living 1: Deathless 6 Quote Share this post Link to post
Maribo Posted November 13, 2021 Talking to kvothesixstring about favorite pwads last night in their stream made me consider a list to contribute to this thread: 9: No Chance 8: Wormwood (link) 7: Deus Vult 7: Swim With the Whales 6: Vanguard 5: Stardate 20x6 3: Scythe 3: Scythe 2 2: Unloved 2: Combat Shock 2 1: Violence 1: Grove 1: The Mucus Empire (link) For fun, some honorable mentions. Spoiler Honorable mentions: Northern Powerhouse + Testing Pool, Bourgeois Megawad, A.L.T., Arrival, Sunlust (probably very highly ranked if I ever finish it), The Mucus Flow, Jenesis, Italo-Doom, Stardate 20x7, Magnolia, Glaive 2, Mayan Mishap, Tangerine Nightmare 3 Quote Share this post Link to post
m8f Posted November 15, 2021 ReaperAA, thanks for the update! Maribo, thank you for voting! Tally updated. 2 Quote Share this post Link to post
baja blast rd. Posted January 5, 2022 Might as well update this. Sunlust - 8 Lost Civilization - 7 Counterattack - 7 Ancient Aliens - 5 Ozonia - 5 Heartland - 5 Nihility - 5 Tarnsman's Projectile Hell - 5 The Wayfarer - 4 Abandon - 4 bonus stuff for fun: 11-20 (no order): Arrival, Back to Basics, Doom 2 in Spain Only, Going Down, Fractured Worlds, Valiant, The Adventures of Square, Back to Saturn X episode 2, Eviternity, Japanese Community Project the difference between my 8th favorite thing of all time and 30th would be like 0.2/5 on a 5-star scale, if I had to rate them, so 21-30 and 11-20 are really close favorite authors of either standalone maps or "that really cool map in a project" (no order): Xaser, RonnieJamesDiner, Dobu Gabu Maru, tourniquet, yakfak, Nanka Kurashiki, AtronX, lupinx-Kassman, Death-Destiny favorite OSTs (ordered): BTSX OST (e1, e2, bootleg BTSX, e3, and the Saxophone-Only Cut) Ancient Aliens OST Time Tripper OST 10 Quote Share this post Link to post
LadyMistDragon Posted January 6, 2022 10 points to 180 Minutes Por Vivre 9 points to Alien Vendetta 8 points to Ancient Aliens 7 point to Eviternity 6 points to Memento Mori II 5 points to Eternal Doom 4 points to Going Down 3 points to Doom: The Way Id Did 2 points to Memento Mori 1 point to 1000 Lines Community Project 3 6 Quote Share this post Link to post
DoomPlayer00 Posted January 15, 2022 10 points to Back to Saturn X Episode 1 9 points to Back to Saturn X Episode 2 8 points to Eviternity 7 points to Sunlust 6 points to Plutonia 2 5 points to Ashes 2063 4 points to Plutonia 2 3 points to Memento Mori 2 2 points to Antaresian Reliquary 1 points to Fragport 3 Quote Share this post Link to post
m8f Posted January 16, 2022 rd, thank you for the update! LadyMistDragon, your points hasn't changed since last time. DoomPlayer00, thank you for voting! 2 Quote Share this post Link to post
ReaperAA Posted January 16, 2022 41 minutes ago, m8f said: LadyMistDragon, your points hasn't changed since last time. They assigned 1 point to 1000 Lines 3 CP now, which was previously assigned to Newdoom Community Project 3 Quote Share this post Link to post
m8f Posted January 16, 2022 Ah! My bad. ReaperAA, thanks for the heads up! LadyMistDragon, thanks for the update! Tally updated and fixed. 4 Quote Share this post Link to post
TheNekroFaker Posted February 5, 2022 Hello, The topic is still alive? 0 Quote Share this post Link to post
ReaperAA Posted February 5, 2022 1 minute ago, TheNekroFaker said: Hello, The topic is still alive? Of course it is. Feel free to vote your favorite wads 3 Quote Share this post Link to post
sincity2100 Posted February 5, 2022 10 points - Ancient Aliens 9 points - Eviternity 8 points - Valiant 7 points - TNT Revilution 6 points - Scythe 5 points - Going Down 4 points - Community Chest 3 3 points - Ancient Aliens 2 points - Community Chest 4 1 point - 2001 A Doom Odyssey 5 Quote Share this post Link to post
ReaperAA Posted February 5, 2022 List update again!!! After watching Dario play Valiant, I decided to play some of Valiant myself and it ended up increasing my liking for Valiant again. So other changes are there as well like Heartland is now at top. Same 10 wads in the list but their positions are changed. 10: Heartland 9: Eviternity 8: Valiant 7: 1000 Lines 3 CP 6: Faithless/ Faithless Trilogy 5: Plutonia 2 4: TNT: Revilution 3: Alien Vendetta 2: Ancient Aliens 1: No Rest For The Living Older list Spoiler 10: Eviternity 9: Heartland 8: Faithless/ Faithless Trilogy 7: 1000 Lines 3 CP 6: Plutonia 2 5: TNT: Revilution 4: Alien Vendetta 3: Valiant 2: Ancient Aliens 1: No Rest For The Living 5 Quote Share this post Link to post
m8f Posted February 9, 2022 sincity2100, thank you for voting! Note that you have assigned Ancient Aliens both 10 and 3 points. The second entry wasn't counted, so you still have 3 points left. ReaperAA, thanks for the update! Top 100 WADs ranked by average vote (only WADs with at least 3 voters are counted): Spoiler ZDoom Community Map Project II Dwango5 Lost Civilization Disturbia Eviternity Abandon Hurt A.L.T. Rowdy Rudy II: POWERTRIP! Doom 64: Retribution Nuts Threshold of Pain Sunder Equinox Batman Doom Ancient Aliens Icarus: Alien Vanguard Valiant Scythe 2 The Adventures of Square Hellbound Heartland Newgothic Movement 2 Aliens TC Slaughterfest 2011 Congestion 1024 No End in Sight Speed of Doom Struggle - Antaresian Legacy Eternal Slumber Party Alien Vendetta Community Chest 3 UAC Ultra Scythe Deus Vult II Back to Saturn X E2: Tower in the Fountain of Sparks Phobos: Anomaly Reborn REKKR Doom II the Way id Did Sunlust Epic 2 Eternal Doom Dark Encounters Faithless Legacy of Heroes TNT: Revilution Going Down No Rest for the Living Swim With the Whales Winter's Fury Community Chest 2 Lunatic STRAIN Pirate Doom Back to Saturn X E1: Get Out of My Stations Resurgence Zone 300 Hell Revealed Brutal Doom: Hell on Earth Starter Pack (Extermination Day) Memento Mori The Plutonia Experiment Counterattack Doom Zero Nihility: Infinite Teeth The Brotherhood of Ruin Plutonia 2 Kama Sutra Requiem SIGIL Perdition's Gate Knee-Deep in ZDoom Community Chest 4 Arcadia Demade Stardate 20X7 Urban Brawl: Action Doom 2 Suspended in Dusk Breach Memento Mori 2 Paradise Reverie The Darkening Episode 2 The Enigma Episode Vela Pax Vanguard Phobos Mission Control Doom the Way id Did Unloved Hell Revealed II Antaresian Reliquary Bauhaus ZPack Plutonia: Revisited Community Project Stardate 20X6 Japanese Community Project (JPCP) Foursite Wow Tech Gone Bad The Ultimate Torment & Torture Brigandine Harmony One more thing. If anyone waits to vote until I process the existing votes, please do not wait. It's easier to do in bulk. 4 Quote Share this post Link to post
RHhe82 Posted February 10, 2022 (edited) I suppose I can change my votes later, but I have finally played enough to even start thinking of votes. So: 1. Going Down - 8 pts. 2. Valiant - 8 pts. 3. Tangerine Nightmare - 8 pts. 4. TNT: Revilution - 7 pts. 5. Interception II - 6 pts. 6. Coffee Break - 5 pts. 7. No Rest for the Living - 4 pts. 8. Crumpets - 4 pts. 9. Scythe - 3 pts. 10. Plutonia Experiment - 2 pts. (Edit: I’m currently playing Ancient Aliens, Sunlust, such wads, so I’d expect the list will be revamped sooner or later. The thing, I’d rather vote for less famous wads, because everybody knows of the blockbusters, and for me it doesn’t add anything if Ancient Aliens would gain even more lead than it has now, even it is totally earned). Edited February 10, 2022 by RHhe82 4 Quote Share this post Link to post
Katamori Posted February 13, 2022 (edited) Stronghold: On the Edge of Chaos - 10 pts BDP37: AUGER;ZENITH - 10 pts Claustrophobia 1024 - 9 pts Hell Ground - 7 pts Revolution! (TVR) - 6 pts Hell To Pay - 5 pts Eternal Doom - 4 pts TNT: Evilution - 2 pts H2H: Xmas - 1 pts Epic 2 - 1 pts Also I know it's obnoxious to talk about myself but thanks for those who voted Somewhere in Time, I never would have ever guessed I could get a place on this list. I'm flattered. Edited February 13, 2022 by Katamori 2 Quote Share this post Link to post
dei_eldren Posted February 19, 2022 On 6/24/2021 at 3:12 AM, dei_eldren said: SiGil - 7 Moonblood - 6 Ozonia - 6 Sign of Torment - 6 TNT Goes Boom! Episode 1 - 5 Lunar Outpost 359 - 5 Endless Torture - 4 Hellish Rogues - 4 TNT: Revilution - 4 Eternal Doom - 3 Kama Sutra - 3 Eviternity - 2 Update time... Will have to increase the amount of voted sets, resulting in few less points for most everyone. :/ SiGil - 7 Moonblood - 5 Sign of Torment - 5 Doom the Way Id Did - 5 Hell Revealed - 5 Doom Island - 4 Favillesco Episode 1: Genuflected on Io - 4 Endless Torture - 4 Hellish Rogues - 3 Lunar Outpost 359 - 3 Valiant - 3 Ozonia - 3 Kama Sutra - 2 Eviternity - 2 2 Quote Share this post Link to post
m8f Posted February 20, 2022 RHhe82, Katamori, thank you for voting! dei_eldren, thanks for the update! Tally updated. 3 Quote Share this post Link to post
ReaperAA Posted March 5, 2022 I wasn't planning to update this soon again, but after playing Good Morning Phobos (thanks to MtPain27) and seeing how low it is placed in this thread, I feel compelled to give it some points. Very nice and underrated wad. Also points changes for other wads. Valiant and AA got ranked higher. 10: Heartland 9: Valiant 8: Eviternity 7: Ancient Aliens 6: 1000 Lines 3 CP 5: Good Morning Phobos 4: Faithless/ Faithless Trilogy 3: Plutonia 2 2: TNT: Revilution 1: Alien Vendetta Older List: Spoiler 10: Heartland 9: Eviternity 8: Valiant 7: 1000 Lines 3 CP 6: Faithless/ Faithless Trilogy 5: Plutonia 2 4: TNT: Revilution 3: Alien Vendetta 2: Ancient Aliens 1: No Rest For The Living 4 Quote Share this post Link to post
m8f Posted March 6, 2022 ReaperAA, thanks for voting! Tally updated. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post
Bryan T Posted March 6, 2022 I'd like to give my final 5 points to EDay, otherwise known as the brutal doom campaign. I recently played through the stripped out version and found it to be excellent. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post
erzboesewicht Posted March 6, 2022 (edited) First time to participate here, as before I think I hadn't really played enough wads. Expect me to change vote at least every year or so as there's still much to go ... Only fan-made PWADs, no IWADs, and I liked several others but these are the "top" ones. Valiant - 6 Eternal Doom - 6 Sunlust - 6 Going Down - 3 Memento Mori 2 - 3 Alien Vendetta - 3 Doom 2 The Way Id Did - 2 Doom 2 In Name Only - 2 Back To Saturn X E1 - 2 Urania - 2 Scythe 2 - 2 Lunatic - 2 Japanese Community Project - 2 Doom Zero - 2 Ancient Aliens - 2 Memento Mori - 2 The Enigma Episode - 2 Back To Saturn X E2 - 2 Doom The Way Id Did - 2 Eviternity - 2 (Edited: sorry, I missed the 20 wad limit, and did some last minute changes that confused me with the numbers. Thanks ReaperAA for reminding :) ) Edited March 6, 2022 by erzboesewicht 2 Quote Share this post Link to post
ReaperAA Posted March 6, 2022 2 minutes ago, erzboesewicht said: First time to participate here, as before I think I hadn't really played enough wads. Expect me to change vote at least every year or so as there's still much to go ... Only fan-made PWADs, no IWADs, and I liked several others but these are the "top" ones. You can only choose a maximum of 20 wads and assign 55 points. You chose 24 wads and assigned 56 points. 3 Quote Share this post Link to post
Kinetic Posted March 6, 2022 Magnolia - 10 Stardate 20x7 - 8 Dimensions - 7 Finely Crafted Fetish Film - 7 Flotsam - 5 The Event Horizon - 5 Wormwood EU - 4 Micro Slaughter Community Project - 3 Death In Excess - 3 Entropy - 3 7 Quote Share this post Link to post
Dubium Posted March 18, 2022 1. The Plutonia Experiment - 10 2. Ancient Aliens - 9 3. Valiant - 8 4. Hellbound - 7 5. Back To Saturn X Episode 2 - 6 6. Eviternity - 5 7. Sunlust - 4 8. Heartland - 3 9. TNT Evilution - 2 10. Scythe 2 - 1 5 Quote Share this post Link to post
m8f Posted March 18, 2022 Bryan T, thanks for the update! erzboesewicht, KineticBeverage, Dubium, thank you for voting! Tally updated. 3 Quote Share this post Link to post
Nefelibeta Posted March 18, 2022 On 3/7/2022 at 2:32 AM, KineticBeverage said: Magnolia - 10 Stardate 20x7 - 8 Dimensions - 7 Finely Crafted Fetish Film - 7 Flotsam - 5 The Event Horizon - 5 Wormwood EU - 4 Micro Slaughter Community Project - 3 Death In Excess - 3 Entropy - 3 Average Ribbiks Contents Enjoyer. 3 Quote Share this post Link to post
Nefelibeta Posted March 18, 2022 Miasma - 5 The map that influenced me the most. Mutabor - 5 A (Mostly) fun and wild ride, reminds me of Death-Destiny. Wormwood - 5 Most underrated ribbiks wad. Wormwood EU - 5 More gimmicky than the first one, love dehacked stuff and bouncy walls.Wormwood ]I[: The Horror - 4 - Even more dehacked stuff, minus 1 point because of the lack of bouncy walls. Struggle - 5 Beautiful and revolutionary dehacked gameplay. I've never seen maps that are this blue. Disturbia - 5 Disturbing The Mucus Flow inspired map. Axolotl - 5 Wacky puzzle/gimmick maps, I love how author calls himself Wibbitz in the text file. Stardate 20x7 - 5 Really a nightmare for first timers but high replay value. Good shit. Fractured Worlds - 5 Lovely mix of visual design and combat, it's like stardate20x6 with the coating of stardate20x7. And I think you can vote for your own maps, so... :D The Mucus Empire - 1 5 Quote Share this post Link to post
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.