⬆️ Doomworld Community Top WADs of All Time (resurrected)

[SilverMiner]

Memento Mori 2 - 10

Resurgence - 5

Pirate Doom - 5

Going Down - 1

Plutonia 2 - 8

TNT - Revilution - 3

Kama Sutra - 2

Revolution! - 5

Phobos: Anomaly Reborn - 10

2002 A Doom Odyssey - 6

 

 

[ax34]

5 for Strange Aeons

4 for Action Doom 1

4 for Batman Reborn

5 for Harmony

5 for Doom Tribute

5 for Dawn of Reality

4 for Pleiades

3 for City Assault

4 for so called "City of DooM Part I BETA 1-11" (cod1-11.wad)

5 for Damned City 2

4 for Europe

4 for Neighborhood from Hell

3 for Return of The Triad

[DOEL]

10 - Alien Vendetta

9 - Scythe 2

8 - Hell Revealed 2

7 - Japanese Community Project

6 - Plutonia

5 - Speed of Doom

4 - Epic 2

3 - Unholy Realms

2 - Stardate 20X6

1 - Vanguard

[m8f]

Maintainer needed!

If anyone is willing to continue updating Doomworld Community Top Wads of All Time, please contact me. I have too many projects to keep maintaining this list too.

[joshthenesnerd]

i'd like to give all the points i can to switcheroom.

[m8f]

rdwpa, I_Punch_Demons, SilverMiner, ax34, DOEL, thank you for voting!

 

The tally in the OP has been updated.

 

Again, it would be nice if someone took over maintaining this list. It's not that hard. There is a spreadsheet that manages points and rankings. All I do is putting names and points to the table, and sorting it by point and name. The hardest part is finding the links to wad pages.

[DOEL]

7 hours ago, m8f said:

rdwpa, I_Punch_Demons, SilverMiner, ax34, DOEL, thank you for voting!

 

The tally in the OP has been updated.

 

Again, it would be nice if someone took over maintaining this list. It's not that hard. There is a spreadsheet that manages points and rankings. All I do is putting names and points to the table, and sorting it by point and name. The hardest part is finding the links to wad pages.

 

I'm willing to take over. I can update it at least every 1-3 days.

Edited May 2, 2020 by DOEL

[Deadwing]

Plutonia - 10

Eviternity - 8
Mano Laikas - 8
SIGIL - 6
Scythe - 6
Jenesis - 6
Struggle - 6
Deathless - 2
Ancient Aliens - 2
Plutonia 2 - 1

[ax34]

edit:

5 to Planisphere 2

4 to Harmony

3 to Europe

3 to Pleiades

4 to Strange Aeons

4 to Damned City 2

the rest the same

[jerk-o]

10 to Back to Saturn X episode 3

9 to Back to Saturn X episode 2

9 to Back to Saturn X episode 1

[Chip]

every point in the world to Wow.wad

[DOEL]

6 hours ago, LiT_gam3r said:

every point in the world to Wow.wad

 

The maximum is 10 points. I'll update the list with the new posts tomorrow. After trying some more WADs, I need to update my own list. Community Chest 4 and Nova III have been absolute blasts for me.

Edited May 13, 2020 by DOEL

[soner du]

10 points for Batman Doom
9 points for Suspended in Dusk
8 points for REKKR
7 points for Ancient Aliens
6 points for Alien Vendetta
5 points for Plutonia 2
4 points for 2002 A Doom Odyssey
3 points for Demonfear
2 points for Endless Torture
1 point for Nostromo's Run

Edited May 13, 2020 by soner du

[Pierrot]

10 Kama Sutra
9  Speed of Doom
8  Scythe 2
7  Plutonia 2
6  Survive in Hell
5  50 Shades of Graytall
4  Hell Ground
3  Community Chest 4
2  Armadosia - The Mad Corridor
1  Whitemare

[P41R47]

10 - TNT: Revilution

10 - Vile Flesh

10 - Revolution! (TVR!)

5 - Kama Sutra

5 - Hell 2 Pay

5 - Perdition's Gate

5 - Demonfear
5 - A.L.T.

Maybe i will change it as i replay more, but those are my top fave that i play over and over from time to time.

Edited May 13, 2020 by P41R47

[Pixel Fiend]

8 - Ancient Aliens

 

6 - Eviternity

6 - Paradise

6 - Dark Universe

6 - Sunlust

6 - Sunder

6 - Back To Saturn X Episode 2

6 - Back To Saturn X Episode 1

 

5 - Deus Vult II

 

 

 

[Hansen79]

5 - Sunlust
5 - Back To Saturn X Episode 2
5 - Ancient Aliens
5 - Going Down
5 - Back To Saturn X Episode 1
5 - Eviternity
5 - Valiant
5 - Stardate 20X6
5 - A.L.T.

4 - Dimension of The Boomed

3 - Congestion 1024
3 - Counterattack

 

 

 

[Woolie Wool]

10 points - Back to Saturn X E2

9 points - Eviternity

8 points - The Adventures of Square

7 points - Eternal Doom

6 points - Valiant

5 points - The Legacy of Heroes

4 points - Alien Vendetta

3 points - Hellforged

2 points - Back to Saturn X E1

1 point - Doom 64 for Doom II

Edited June 12, 2020 by Woolie Wool

[m8f]

The tally in the OP has been updated.

 

Deadwing, Pierrot, Hansen79, thanks for voting!

 

ax34, soner du, Woolie Wool, thanks for updating your votes!

 

jerk-o, LiT_gam3r, P41R47, <<Rewind, please read the rules:

Quote

you can vote for 10 to 20 of your favourite WADs and you have up to 55 points to allocate any way you wish, with a maximum of 10 points for any particular release.

 

[smeghammer]

Oooh this is hard... What I play changes over time. Ones I keep coming back to (in no particular order):

 

 - 2002 ADO (Doom 1) - 3

 - Breach - 3

 - Vrack2 - 3

 - Firetop Mountain - 5

 - Ancient Aliens - 3

 - Strain - 5

 - Armadosia - 6

 - Dark7/D7MP1 - 4

 - Kama Sutra - 5

 - ZBloodPack - 5

 - P:AR - 6

 - Demon Driver (Fat Yngwee!) - 3

 - Somewhere in Time (Iron Maiden, obviously...) - 4

 

Loads more but these stand out (today)

 

And then there is that level I played several years ago that I can't -ing remember what it was called!! That would be in this list too.

 

[DoomDork]

10: Scythe 2

9: Ancient Aliens

8: Scythe

7: Resurgence

6: Valiant

5: Going Down

4: Alien Vendetta

3: Preacher

2: Extermination Day

1: Jenesis

[Endless]

Holy hell, the sheer amount of WADs there is. Alright I'll try this lol

 

10: Scythe

9: Alien Vendetta

7: Eviternity

8: Back to Saturn X E1

7: Community Chest 4

6: Memento Mori

5: Void

4: Doom the way Id Did

3: 2002: A Doom Odyssey

2: No Rest for the Living

1: Japanese Community Project

 

Hell, theres probably more but to tell you the truth, I barely remember any of those lol I sure remember that I enjoy them a lot, specially Scythe and 2002, those were some of my first, but the rest, damn, I need to play them again.

PS: I loooove this list.

[m8f]

smeghammer, DoomDork, thank you for voting!

 

The tally in the OP has been updated.

 

@Endless, you have exceeded point limit (55). Your point sum is 62.

 

Also, a reminder for @P41R47 and @<<Rewind that your votes haven't been counted yet because the rule is to vote for at least 10 WADs.

(not pinging jerk-o and LiT_gam3r because of obviously joke posts)

[P41R47]

14 minutes ago, m8f said:

Also, a reminder for @P41R47 and @<<Rewind that your votes haven't been counted yet because the rule is to vote for at least 10 WADs.

Alrighty!

So here is the new one:

 

10 - TNT: Revilution

9 - Vile Flesh

8 - Kama Sutra

7 - A.L.T.

6 - The Journey

3 - Perdition's Gate

3 - Hell 2 Pay

3 - Revolution! (TVR!)

3 - Demonfear

3 - Fragport

 

Now is right! This is my latest favorite list. I think i prefer Vanilla megawads than anything...

 

[Endless]

3 hours ago, m8f said:

smeghammer, DoomDork, thank you for voting!

 

The tally in the OP has been updated.

 

@Endless, you have exceeded point limit (55). Your point sum is 62.

 

Also, a reminder for @P41R47 and @<<Rewind that your votes haven't been counted yet because the rule is to vote for at least 10 WADs.

(not pinging jerk-o and LiT_gam3r because of obviously joke posts)

Sh*t sorry mate, didnt catch the instructions well ! My bad bud.

 

10: Scythe

8: Lost Civilization

8: Eviternity

7: Back to Saturn X E1

6: No Rest for the Living

5: Japanese Community Project

3: Community Chest 4

3: Doom 2 the way Id Did

2: Doom the way Id Did

1: 2002: A Doom Odyssey

1: Memeto Mori

1: Alien Vendetta

 

Hopefully I got the math right lol.

[Pixel Fiend]

Fixed. Now adheres to wad count requirement.

 

Ancient Aliens

Rewind: 10

 

Eviternity

Rewind: 6

 

Paradise

Rewind: 6

 

Dark Universe

Rewind: 6

 

Sunlust

Rewind: 6

 

Sunder

Rewind: 6

 

Deus Vult II

Rewind: 5

 

Back To Saturn X Episode 1

Rewind: 4

 

Back To Saturn X Episode 2

Rewind: 4

 

Sigil

Rewind: 2

 

 

[m8f]

P41R47, Endless, <<Rewind, thank you for voting!

 

The tally in the OP has been updated.

[m8f]

In case of somebody is curious about the update process:

 

By the way, if anyone still wants to maintain this thread instead of me, please let me know. It isn't difficult.

Edited June 27, 2020 by m8f

[Pixel Fiend]

2 hours ago, m8f said:

In case of somebody is curious about the update process:

 

By the way, if anyone still wants to maintain this thread instead of me, please let me know. It isn't difficult.

 

Wow, most excellent work! Thank you so much for going to the effort of keeping this alive. I'm glad you have a way to partially automate the process. I voted for relatively new wads so you had to search for them. Such don't have a chance to keep up with what people have already voted for. For instance, the extremely detailed wad Refracted Reality isn't featured yet.

Edited June 27, 2020 by <<Rewind

[m8f]

Yep, old and well-known works have the advantage here, and this is a problem. I thought that would be mitigated by influx of new users who like modern WADs more, but it doesn't happen for some reason.

 

Also, not much users update their votes.