Does Mayonnaise belong on pizza?

[Biodegradable]

It contains neither pine nor apple. It is the fruit of lies!

[snapshot]

As long as there's no anchovies

[NoXion]

The problem I think with anchovies is that they have such a strong flavour, that they overwhelm everything else on the pizza.

[[McD] James]

Just now, NoXion said:

The problem I think with anchovies is that they have such a strong flavour, that they overwhelm everything else on the pizza.

 

One slice of pizza with anchovies is great. But after the first slice, all you can taste is anchovies. 

[Doom_Dude]

31 minutes ago, Doomkid said:

I love pineapple on pizza, I know that makes me a Heretic, but mayo is too far for me personally.

 

What about vegemite? ;)

[TenenteZashu]

18 minutes ago, Smouths said:

My 2 cents now that the pineapple wars have begun:

 

My personal favorite pizza is topped with pineapple, pepperoni, red onion, and banana peppers- I don't like pairing pineapple with ham, oddly enough.

 

Gotta dip said pizza in a side of buffalo sauce though. One time I mixed mayo in with the buffalo sauce and it was pretty good, but I prefer just buffalo.

In my opinion pineapple is better with white onions because they're a bit more stronger than the red ones and so they balance the taste of the pineapple

[captain caleb]

[Smoothandz]

2 minutes ago, Doom_Dude said:

 

What about vegemite? ;)

 

Um... What? Is it because I'm American that I haven't heard of vegemite? 

[Doom_Dude]

 

10 minutes ago, Smoothandz said:

 

Um... What? Is it because I'm American that I haven't heard of vegemite? 

 

I dunno why. I'm Canadian and know about vegemite. I've never had it myself, but did try it's little brother Marmite and it was pretty foul. haha.

 

I have never put mayo on pizza. Doesn't sound all that appealing.

 

I've made a few hundred pizzas, probably more. Sometimes I'll grate cheddar and mozza together on top, like this one I made a few months ago.

Edited September 24, 2020 by Doom_Dude

[[McD] James]

Alfredo sauce is pretty good on pizza. I know it might not sound all that appealing, but it's worth experiencing. Goes good with mushrooms and sausages. 

[Biodegradable]

That is a handsome looking pizza, @Doom_Dude. I bet it was delicious.

[Smoothandz]

5 minutes ago, Doom_Dude said:

 

 

I dunno why. I'm Canadian and know about vegemite. I've never had it myself, but did try it's little brother Marmite and it was pretty foul. haha.

 

I don't think mayo would be all that great on pizza. I can see it probably getting very liguid-fied and making things soupy... maybe.

 

I've made a few hundred pizzas, probably more. Sometimes I'll grate cheddar and mozza together on top, like this one I made a few months ago.

 

Why hello there, neighbor up north! I also enjoy adding different cheeses to my pizza. Have you tried gouda?

[esselfortium]

Pineapple on pizza is fantastic with the right savory toppings to contrast against.

 

Mayo I dunno. I've heard it's common in Japan, and I guess I could imagine it working with the Kewpie mayo they sell over there, which is a pretty good all-purpose flavor enhancer. I've had pizza with aioli on it, which is kind of a similar idea, it was tasty but it was such a heavy meal I felt like it took a few years off my life.

[Doom_Dude]

1 minute ago, Biodegradable said:

That is a handsome looking pizza, @Doom_Dude. I bet it was delicious.

Thanks. It was pretty tasty actually. ;)

 

Just now, Smoothandz said:

Why hello there, neighbor up north! I also enjoy adding different cheeses to my pizza. Have you tried gouda?

Greetings. Yes, smoked gouda is good on pizza and other places like crackers and such.

 

1 minute ago, esselfortium said:

Pineapple on pizza is fantastic with the right savory toppings to contrast against.

 

Mayo I dunno. I've heard it's common in Japan, and I guess I could imagine it working with the Kewpie mayo they sell over there, which is a pretty good all-purpose flavor enhancer. I've had pizza with aioli on it, which is kind of a similar idea, it was tasty but it was such a heavy meal I felt like it took a few years off my life.

That reminds me of this spicy mayo that came with a steak fajita kit, which was pretty damned good. I think the mayo was just mixed with some cayenne pepper. That might be doable....

[kalaeth]

41 minutes ago, Biodegradable said:

It contains neither pine nor apple. It is the fruit of lies!

fun fact : 

it's called Ananas or close to it in almost every other language. Even russian : Анана́с!

[Egg Boy]

I work at a pizza place, and I like to think I know what I like on a pizza. I always make myself pineapple, jalapeno and bacon. Its sweet, spicy, and bit crunchy. Why, that's almost the entire food pyramid.

[TheMagicMushroomMan]

3 hours ago, Mayomancer said:

It's not like i always eat pizza with mayo on it, but i do like to put it on let's say, a pepperoni pizza for example, specially if it's seasoned or spicy mayonnaise. Most of the time i just put some olive oil and hot sauce on pizza. The thing is, when i mention i do that i get quite the strong reaction from people mostly against it, why is that? A lot of pizza places where i live even send some mayo with the pizzas they make, maybe it's a cultural thing?

 

What's your take on it?

 

Username checks out.

 

No mayo for me. On anything, really.

[Nine Inch Heels]

Pizza is already a pretty "rich" dish, and a well made one is so damn tasty that it doesn't need anything more added to it.

 

Adding a condiment to pizza (especially the greasy pizza chain crap) which is basically made from +90% pure fat sounds like a sure fire way to get obese and develop diabetes in the process.

 

I don't even care about what people think may or may not belong on pizza, but fuck sakes does it sound unhealthy...

Edited September 24, 2020 by Nine Inch Heels

[Pokemanic33]

Mayonnaise doesn't belong on anything and pizza is too sacred to be tainted by it

[Dr. Toboggan]

Lol

[TwinBeast]

Never tried with mayo. I've put some guacamole on pizza, that was pretty good. Suppose it's healthier too.

 

Also about pineapple, yea sure it's good, but kiwi fruit is better.

[Redneckerz]

>Looks at question title

<Looks at user name

 

Ah. I see how it is.

[AtticTelephone]

The only sauce I put on my pizza is Ranch.

[AtticTelephone]

Oh, also, pineapple pizza is evil and was made by the Icon of Sin in Post Hell.

[nname]

Wha-

 

No.

[wolfmcbeard]

Mayo pizza is a cursed item.

[Zolgia108]

another italian is here? and he said that mayo is okay? dammit. disgraceful. just joking @TenenteZashu

Fact is that mayo is used together with ketchup to make a disgusting pink sauce that sometimes is used on shrimps, this doesn't mean that it's okay on pizza, i mean... but yea you can eat whatever pleases you the important thing is that you like it. When i was cooking in arizona some people (from canada btw @Clippy) used to put tabasco sauce on my pasta and i hated them, then i realized it's just a matter of taste and now i don't really care anymore. You can even eat pineapple pizza for what i care^^

JUST DON'T CALL CARBONARA THAT SHIT FROM GOR(g)ON RAMSEY PLEASE.

 

[The_SloVinator]

Hell yea. Love me some mayo on pizza. <3

[Cruduxy Pegg]

Not as good as ranch pizza.

[kwc]

kwc's stinky pizza:
Sweet Chili Thai Sauce, Mozarella + Goat + Feta cheese, Sweet Garlic + Pepper seasoning

If you can find a place that makes it, try it. It's good and nobody else will ask for a slice.