Doom Tierlist

[DoomGuy999]

Tier list of the doom games rated by the community. I'm just curious about how everyone feels on the series. Note I will slowly update and add more tiers to the poll.

 

Using

S

A

B

C

D

F

Edited January 6, 2024 by DoomGuy999

[Doomkid]

(I don't know the name) the CD with 2000 levels is in close contention with Master Levels and Mighty Doom! The rest I could take or leave.

[Li'l devil]

How does this even work? I only see S-tier for instance. Where's F tier so that I can vote 3DO and Saturn versions there?

[97th Century Fox]

I wonder if the Unity port addons can be counted.

[OniriA]

K C A S L L A B

 

From right to left.

[Argent Agent]

Where is D tier so I can put Requiem there

(Also makes me think I should make a deathmatch-wad tier list)

[Cutman 999]

Uh... why instead of a poll, you just don't pass a link to a tier list maker template?

Edited January 6, 2024 by Cutman 999

[sandwedge]

my favourite doom game is GZDoom (Unofficial Doom Enhancer)!  I just can't get enough of it!

[yakfak]

s tier: nrftl, sigil, master levels and doom 2   imo

most of the conversions to consoles are just slightly damaged versions of doom.exe with no additional content, only psx doom is interesting iirc

 

[Fonze]

I am very confused by the poll options but I went with nrftl, final doom, and doom 2 in the first poll and... uh I guess gzdoom in the second because pwad support? Idk what we're voting on.

[DoomGuy999]

1 hour ago, Li'l devil said:

How does this even work? I only see S-tier for instance. Where's F tier so that I can vote 3DO and Saturn versions there?

It was very painful just to put 35 options for s tier, so later I'll get to f tier

[DoomGuy999]

39 minutes ago, Fonze said:

I am very confused by the poll options but I went with nrftl, final doom, and doom 2 in the first poll and... uh I guess gzdoom in the second because pwad support? Idk what we're voting on.

This is a tierlist. Doom world only allows 20 options per question, so no matter what you are voting for which deserve s tier right now.

[DoomGuy999]

53 minutes ago, sandwedge said:

my favourite doom game is GZDoom (Unofficial Doom Enhancer)!  I just can't get enough of it!

I put gzdoom up there since it is classic doom modernized

[DoomGuy999]

1 hour ago, Doomkid said:

(I don't know the name) the CD with 2000 levels is in close contention with Master Levels and Mighty Doom! The rest I could take or leave.

Do you know what that CD was called with the doom levels? I think it came with the master levels.

[MoiraHeart]

Uhhh I don't see pregnancy test Doom in the list? Such a weird thing to omit, it's my favorite port.

[DoomGuy999]

1 minute ago, MoiraHeart said:

Uhhh I don't see pregnancy test Doom in the list? Such a weird thing to omit, it's my favorite port.

Not an official port.

 

Sorry, I can make a doom port tierlist.

[sandwedge]

GZDoom is also not an official port.

[DoomGuy999]

2 hours ago, Doomkid said:

(I don't know the name) the CD with 2000 levels is in close contention with Master Levels and Mighty Doom! The rest I could take or leave.

Nevermind, I figured out it's called Maximum Doom

[LadyMistDragon]

every version of doom is equally awesome? lol, this probably is not a format that belongs on a forum