KING ELVIS Posted June 28, 2000 I do not need any music... ...that's because I have those whispering voices in my head :D 0 Share this post Link to post
Chief Posted June 28, 2000 NIN and Doom 3 together... that would be my favourite artist and game ALL IN ONE... holy shit, I gotta go and upgrade now. Hey Lüt, I have found you can find, Happiness in Slavery. 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Slipgate Posted June 28, 2000 Hello, I wouldn't normally get involved in this stuff, but just a note to Caleb: You claim that the doom community can make up its mind about what it thinks about this without Lut or anyone's help. Well, all Lut and these others are doing IS showing their own opinions, which is what everyone else is doing too. People are making up their own minds, just like you seem to want, but Lut and these "others" you mention aren't doing anything but ALSO making up their own minds. That hardly requires harassing them. This comment thread, based on the post its a part of, is GOING to be people discussing their opinions on this very matter with each other. And that's what's transpiring. No need to yell and scream at anybody in particular right now. Your own post where you got upset at Lut and these others included you stating your own opinion as well, which is all the ones you are yelling at did. Slipgate 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Anonymous User Posted June 28, 2000 Slipgate, Caleb was making a good point, they couldnt do things as good as Reznor. He was not harrassing them, he was making a good point. 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Anonymous User Posted June 28, 2000 One of the things that made Doom's music so great is that it scared the &$*$%*@ out of you. Hard Rock/Industrial does not do that. We need something that makes the hair on the back of you neck stand up. eg.. E1M8(Phobos Anomoly) and E2M7(Spawning Vats). 0 Share this post Link to post
Lüt Posted June 28, 2000 I didn't say that with the intent of pissing off NIN fans, I did it because I don't like the guy. He did pretty good with his first and second records, despite the laughably cheesy drumkits on Broken. The other two are just him PLAYING AROUND! Cripes. That's all I had to say. Usually I prefer a bit of professionalism in my music, but if you guys don't, that's perfectly fine with me. 0 Share this post Link to post
Swedish Fish Posted June 28, 2000 <HTML>While I think that Bobby coming back for DOOM 3 would be the ultimate I have no problem with Reznor making some DOOM music. If anyone remembers back in '97 + '98 people were always using NIN music in pwads. It was a natural fit to doom's atmosphere. Heck, NIN is already carved into E4M1. I'm getting sick of "fickle" music listeners. I bet you Lüt is one of those guys who likes a band when it's popular and then jumps the bandwagon for the newest latest crap. How about sticking your balls behind a band you like? So then we can make fun of how they've had ups and downs and the fact they don't fit in with our particular tastes. </HTML> 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest lau Posted June 28, 2000 OK...some ppl like NIN, some doesn't...Who cares if it's NIN or someone else if the music is good? Don't say it'll be crap until you hear it... And it's not done yet... 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Anonymous User Posted June 28, 2000 the Quake1 soundtrack (which I quite enjoyed; excellent post-industrial ambient) was the first time I ever heard of NIN, and I was quite disappointed to find out that the rest of NIN's work was some sort of industrial-degenerated-into-pop... the man wrote some of the "music" for the incredibly shallow marylin manson, mr. "image poorly hiding lack of substance" himself? yuck. But, the Quake music proves that he can do better... Whether his work fits DOOM, we'll have to see; and it's not certain he'll do it, so far. 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest bigmike57 Posted June 28, 2000 www.doomworld.net, is a ripoff of www.doomworld.com, the page sux it's ugly as sin 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Gorc Posted June 28, 2000 Just because nobody uses midi tracks in games anymore doesn't mean Bobby Prince can't do the music. Heck, all he has to do is write it. Someone else could do it. My choice would be Sonic Mayhem, who did Quake IIs kickass tracks. 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Anonymous User Posted June 28, 2000 To all you NIN HATERS FUCK YOU AND GET OFF THIS SITE!!!!!NIN is perfect for DOOM and was talor made for it..I dont want pointless hard music when im playin DOOM 3!!!I want music that makes sense, and consistant with the story and atmosphere!!!!DOOM has always been a FPS Horror game with weird demonic shit in it, ambient music fits the scenerio. Im a hardcore DOOM fan myself, but Bobby Prince was good for it's 486 times,the music was good but outdated. Now we have Reznor (who is a damn talented musician)to score ,and updated DOOM with some grim ,moody, kick ass,dark music. Industrial music fit well in the DOOM world also because half(if not most)of the DOOM monsters are BIO-Mechanical demons right?.So NIN could also do the sound effects too!!Hard shit like Zombie or Pantera(all good music)will kill the morbid atmosphere of DOOM. DOOM's history is all about the scare, you will only kill that scare with fast metal.Metal(or hard industrial) worked in Quake 2 because the world was not a horror focus,but more towards science fiction. Instead of fighting Demonic hellspawns(QUAKE), you were fighting mindless cyborgs(QUAKE 2).Besides their was hardly any Hard Rock in DOOM1 or 2????!! PS. Not only should NIN score this game, but also the MOVIE!!!! 0 Share this post Link to post
Jon Posted June 28, 2000 To all you NIN LOVERS FUCK YOU AND GET OFF THIS SITE!!!!!NIN is NOT perfect for DOOM and wasn't talor made for it..I dont want pointless NIN music when im playin DOOM 3!!!I want music that makes sense, and consistant with the story and atmosphere!!!! LIKE BOBBY PRINCE! God It makes as much sense. 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Anonymous User Posted June 28, 2000 To all you NIN HATERS FUCK YOU AND GET OFF THIS SITE!!!!!NIN is perfect for DOOM and was talor made for it..I dont want pointless hard music when im playin DOOM 3!!!I want music that makes sense, and consistant with the story and atmosphere!!!!Prince is good ,but old school. GOD IT MAKES SO MUCH SENSE!!!!! 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Anonymous User Posted June 28, 2000 i think they should use death metal like morbid angel that way the game would not just be for pussies 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest lau Posted June 29, 2000 this is pointless... if ID decides NIN is ok, they'll do songs for doom3, if ID thinks NIN's music is not ok for doom, they'll choose something else... They wont choose NIN or not if 10 ppl in here are saying "oh no! Not NIN!" and 10 others are saying "Yeah! NIN rules!". It seems that this communauty loves to argue for pointless subjects (remember the revenant's pants or the DooM/DOOM debate?). Who cares??? If the music if good and done by NIN, ok. If the music is good and not done by NIN, ok. Dont say Bobby Prince is old school or NIN sucks, just wait and say (Bobby Prince/NIN/someone else) did some cool Doom3 musics or (Bobby Prince/NIN/someone else) did some crappy Doom3 musics. Just wait and say all this shit when doom3 (or DooM3 or DOOM3 or DoomIII) is released... PS: Sorry for my bad english but i'm french... 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Anonymous User Posted June 29, 2000 If any of you had bothered to read the article, nowhere does it say that Id has confirmed having Trent Reznor do the music for Doom3. 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Gorc Posted June 29, 2000 Bobby Prince did all of DooMs sound effects. Well... recorded them at least. Trent Reznor did the same in Quake. If its background noise... water gushing, wind blowing, gunshots etc. then it doesn't MATTER. Both Bobby prince and NIN could do a good job of it. Iau (below) DOES make sense. Lets just see what happens. Good, Bad.... I'm the guy with the gun! 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest ViolentEd Posted June 29, 2000 Hrmmm... I think MDFMK would be able to throw together a nice soundtrack. Techno/Metal/Industrial... But then again... listen to "the sounds of Doom" cd by Bobby Prince, that sounds freaking good. 0 Share this post Link to post
Jon Posted June 29, 2000 It seems people are only thinking of two view-stances here- people who like NIN, and people who dont like NIN. Well, I dont LISTEN to NIN. I dont have a particularly strong opinion on them. BUT I do on Bobby Princes score. I dont think doom3 can get off the ground without him. You may want to combine your love of doom with your love of NIN but you must understand a lot of people dont like NIN, and I'd hope most people here like doom. Dont throw two sets of opinionated eggs in the same basket and potentially alienate what could be a great game for a lot of people. 0 Share this post Link to post
Megalyth Posted June 29, 2000 Why is everyone saying that they don't or do want Nine Inch Nails to do the soundtrack? Trent Reznor isn't Nine Inch Nails. It says plainly in the article that he likes to work outside NiN. So everyone complaining that they don't want NiN to do the soundtrack, your wish is granted. 0 Share this post Link to post
Jon Posted June 29, 2000 Quite true megalyth, although my complaint is not that NIN is doing the sound track, but that bobby prince ISN'T. 0 Share this post Link to post
Megalyth Posted June 29, 2000 That wasn't really aimed at you. I myself hope that Reznor does not do Doom's music, because I didn't like Quake1 music much. Bobby Prince would be nice, but he's it seems like he's faded out since Doom. Sonic Mayhem would be cool, as long as the music was like Quake2 and it's mission packs and not like Quake3. Another thing that seems weird is that during the development of Quake3, Trent Reznor decided not to do the music because video games don't get as mch recognition, or whatever he said, I don't remember. I wonder what changed his mind...($$ahem$$) 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Anonymous User Posted June 29, 2000 Sonic Mayhem would be a good choice..I still would love REZNOR to do the score. You people are braindead!! Quake 1 sounds were excellent!!! NIN might be $$AHEM!!$$, but so is everyone else in the music industry!?!?Metallica in my opinion are the biggest greedy bastards in the industry. I would pretty much take NIN over those fuckin sell-outs anyday. Bobby Prince isnt the only fuckin person to save DOOM3. A good example is the music in DOOM 64, thoughs tracks had me scared through the whole game!! that is why i liked Q1 because the music added to the surreal enviroment. 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Anonymous User Posted June 29, 2000 NiN sucks. Industrial sucks. Bobby Prince rules. Altough (i think it was) E3M3 was written by Slayer.... Slayer doing the soundtrack might be.. uhm.. intresting. Slayer killing Trent Reznor would nicely fall in the 'good ideas' category. 0 Share this post Link to post
Recommended Posts