I would say the same except for FEAR 2, which seems mostly hated. Yes it's a lazy retread of the first game's story, yes they dumbed down lighting and visceral fx, and mechanics, and difficulty hard is hard for all the wrong reasons while normal is a cakewalk, but I still have a lot of fun with it and the DLC kicks ass.
The third game still has enjoyable gunplay, as well as some good set pieces, but I hate the story and the fact Monolith didn't make it, it also somehow looks worse than the prior game despite being two years apart.
Oh yeah and Perseus Mandate is still fun if ugly because of the bizarre omission of lighting, with its own memorable moments.