Obsidian

I'm going to voice the same opinions as the first reviewer and say that you should work on layout. Also, I doubt that this'd work in vanilla due to the map being in UDMF format and having slopes: I'd recommend using Doom Builder for future vanilla maps. I'll give it a 2, but it's still miles better than a Terrywad. - Obsidian

Feels a bit desolate in places, but looks great and plays just as good. 4 well-earned stars. - Obsidian

Pretty decently made, if a bit confusing at times. 3 stars. - Obsidian

Funny basrad, aren't you? :P It's pretty funny, I'll admit that much. I kind of wish you didn't spoil the surprise in the textfile, but oh well. 5 stars for the comedy value. - Obsidian

Decently designed, if a bit claustrophobic. Could use some ironing out in terms of flow, but I enjoyed it all the same and that's what counts. 3 stars. - Obsidian

A STARTAN room with a scattering of weapons and a recoloured Cyberdemon. After you kill it you get teleported into a screamer. That is all. - Obsidian

Killing a Cyb with a Shotgun and Chaingun isn't the easiest of tasks, but kill it I did: I wonder if I missed anything too important. :P It's kind of difficult making out some of the more important bits of architechture with the colour scheme, so I'd recommend some more detail on the walls. It's pretty decent though, so 3 stars. - Obsidian

Large decently detailed techbase map with a somewhat hefty monster count. There's a bit of an ammunition surplus, but it doesn't hold the map back too much. I got killed at the staircase bit where evenants pop up behind you, whic I thought was a wee bit unfair considering the close quarters. Nevertheless, 5 stars. - Obsidian

0_o 1996? Very nice indeed. 4 stars. - Obsidian

Bring the toilet to the computer, of course! Also 4 stars for a well-made map. - Obsidian

Certainly better than my abomination of a first map at any rate(which I haven't uploaded XD). 3 stars. - Obsidian

1997, huh? The map is a rather odd piece of work, with some downright random architechture. It's an alright map, but the 2 building copied directly from Industrial Zone drag this map down to 2 stars. - Obsidian

Basically a Terrywad with the SOMEMONG texture removed: the scripts and loud noises are still present. Ignore viciously. - Obsidian

It's definitely an improvement over some of his earlier work, but it's still ugly and doesn't play that well, and no way is it HR-styled. Work on your gameplay and architecture and for goodness sake stop using triangles so much. 2 stars. - Obsidian

What you'd expect from 1996: it's got decent progression and bland texturing and architechture. 2 stars. - Obsidian

The Icon of Sin is a giant gray wall. Instant 5 stars. - Obsidian

Omg Birthday. Heh, 5 stars. - Obsidian

Just for the record, I'm not the Obsidian who worked on this. :P - Obsidian

Mixed feelings about this map: the detailing is lovely in places, but the map can be so damn claustrophobic somethimes and the gameplay suffers for it. I'd give this 2.5, but I'll round it up instead. :P 3 stars. - Obsidian

Odd little map, this: it makes good use of the stock Doom II textures and manages to convey atmosphere, but the gameplay isn't overly spectacular. It's nice, but there's not much surprises. That aside, it's a decent little map. 3 stars. - Obsidian

VERY well pulled off. The DeHackEd work could use a little more tweaking, but the map as a whole is a lot of fun. 4 stars. - Obsidian

1 star for effort. - Obsidian

It's a nice little blend - like coffee! It felt a bit open at times which kind of ruined the progression, but everything else is pulled off excellently. 4 stars. - Obsidian

FINALLY finished it! An excellent innovative challenge that I would recommend to anyone. 5 stars. - Obsidian

A simple yet nicely detailed map with not too many blatant ZDoomisms. I noticed a HOM behind one of the pillars in the area after the beginning, but other than that it's a decently made map. 3 stars. - Obsidian