m8f

Sorry, made you wait for a month before the vote got in. Updated the list now (along with other voters).

Done. To voters: when voting for a new wad, please add a link to it. It helps a lot.

Thanks, unmarked Kama Sutra and Resurgence.

Marked slaughtermaps in the spreadsheet. Top: Please let me know if I missed something or some maps aren't really slaughter.

Fixed, thanks!

Sorry for the late update. By the way, the list now contains rough information on engine requirements. If you notice any errors, please let me know!

No, there is no separate thread for discussion, please discuss here.

Filtered by year: 2023 Machete Abscission 1x1 Autophagy GOODWAD Limit Buffet Temporal Tantrum Jamal Jones Trilogy Nostalgia 2 Grindfest Jack Builds a Techbase My House (MyHouse.wad) The Great Dog Escape The Pilgrim's Westward Way 2022 Overboard Poogers JUMPWAD Capybara TNT: Threevilution The 10x10 Project Solar Struggle Meowgi's Practice Hub Nostalgia Dance on the Water Beed's Attempt at a Cool Arsenal (BAaaCA) DIY Elementalism The Bikini Bottom Massacre Doom Negative One: Beyond the experiment Journey To Hell Occula Altars of Madness Disarray Pagodia Vesper Wormwood IV: The Final Chapter Anomaly Report Azazel's Second Descent Doom Beneath Dub's Double Feature Ex Inferis Hardfest Hydrosphere Pandora Shades of Azure The Walls WAD

@El Inferno, you have 56 points total. Please remove 1 point. @LadyMistDragon, you have 54 points total. You can leave it as is, or add 1 point now or later.

Done! You can reinstate your points at any time if you want. Replayability isn't the only existing merit, just saying. Nope! You can only lower the position of a wad by voting for other wads.

Agreed. There is no way to measure "best" in the field of entertainment at all, so popularity ranking it is. TCs and standalone games do count, everything doom-related count. It seems that most of the folks here don't consider them "Doom wads", so they rarely occupy top slots. Official expansions are all listed now. Strangely, Doom 64 isn't. For the reference, standalone games in this list: TCs:

Slaughter Map Performance Booster

Sure, as long as there is proof of existence. If I ever forget to change the state of a wad when it's released, please let me know!

I don't have a list of direct links for the files here, so I cannot offer a way to automatically download everything. Most of the WADs here are uploaded to /idgames, others are from ModDB, file sharing services or personal web sites. Maybe Doom Launcher can somewhat facilitate downloading, as it can download from /idgames (I haven't tried it myself).

Miasma - Boom Disturbia - Boom Breach - LR ZDoom Community Map Project II (ZDCMP2) - ZDoom Grove - Boom Elysion - Boom Hurt - ZDoom Brigandine - LR Arcadia Demade - LR Comatose - Boom The Given - LR Foursite - LR ZDoom Community Map Project: Take 1 (ZDCMP) - ZDoom Doom Center - ZDoom Extreme Terror - ZDoom City of the Damned: Apocalypse - ZDoom Holy Hell - LR Grime - vanilla Lullaby - ZDoom Redemption Of The Slain - ZDoom Torment and Torture - ZDoom Monster Hunter Ltd. Part I/Part II - Boom Hellrun - vanilla Mangle - vanilla No Chance - Boom Remnant - LR The Beesong - ZDoom Doom City - vanilla Eden - Boom HSFC - vanilla Odessa 1 - vanilla Waterlab GZD - ZDoom 5till L1 Complex - LR Castle of the Damned - vanilla Cheogsh - ZDoom Saturnine Chapel - Boom Valhalla - ZDoom Brotherhood of Ruin: The Lost Temple - Boom Dawn of Reality - ZDoom Drip Feed - Boom Firetop Mountain - ZDoom Frozen Time - Boom Gateway to Shangri-La - Boom Infraworld - The Hatehammer - Boom Island - vanilla Jade Earth - Boom Okuplok Slaughter Map - Boom Planisphere 2 - LR SELFISH5 - Boom The Egg of Human Endeavors - Boom The Ghoul's Forest 3 - ZDoom UAC Invasion: The Supply Depot - ZDoom Verdant Citadel - ZDoom Chord 2 - vanilla Crimson Horizon - Boom dead.air - ZDoom Neighborhood From Hell - ZDoom Townhouses - vanilla Vrack - Boom Vrack 3 - Boom Balls - ZDoom Bermuda Triangle - Boom Botanic Biosphere - ZDoom Chord 1 - vanilla Chord 3 - LR Chord G - vanilla City Assault - ZDoom DEMON DRIVER!!!! - ZDoom Europe - vanilla IC2005 - Boom Marine Assault - ZDoom Vrack 2 - Boom City of the Damned - ZDoom Ice Rage - ZDoom Jägermörder - 01 : Chemical Lab - Boom Black Room - Boom Castle of Eternal Carrot in the Sky - Boom Demonastery - Boom Hoover Dam - vanilla Hotel Hell - vanilla Lilium - LR My House (MyHouse.wad) - ZDoom Nostromo's Run - vanilla Polygon Base - vanilla Spicy Evil Spaghetti - ZDoom The Eye - Boom The Great Dog Escape - ZDoom The Mucus Empire - Boom The Ultimate Icon of Sin - ZDoom The Walls - vanilla Void - ZDoom