We would need a doom remake but done by iD software... the problem is that they would need to somehow pull off a magic trick to combine all the id tech engines and as GrafZ has told me many times, it can't be done due to technical limitations and differences between iD Tech engines.
I think DOOM has already BEEN mastered... by @Graf Zahl, with his GZDoom source port.
No other source port is as advanced as GZDoom, as far as I know. Not even k8vavoom.