Xim's & Wardust WAD Ratings for total conversions

[WARDUST]

This ratings has the purpose to find faster thouse wads that can fit better with our total conversions (Xim's Star Wars Doom | Darkforces Wardusted)
So, this rating valuate how good is the WAD with our mods on, and not how good is the wad itself (only usefull wads will be posted)
Usually, thouse wads are the ones with mostly vanilla or scifi content. Also, for some mods we can provide extra support like textures or music or monster replacers
Feel free to participate, and we will be upgrading the initial post time to time
 

Concern (Doom1)
Rating - 10
Perfect gameplay, sadness is in Doom1 you can't see some enemies :P

UprisingRC4
Rating - 8
Comments - Fun and dificult,
Problems - some maps impossible without tricks
Map 20 hundred enemies at the end, making lot of lag
Map 28 you must jump in some point (not sure if it's a bug or just i can't find a switch)
Map 29, imposible without iddqd, extreme lag in this final map(thousen enemies)
      
moonbld
Rating - 9
 
Sunlust
Rating - 8
Problems - some texture problems
 
SpacWars
Rating - 8
Textures/Replacers suport
Problems - The final level has a bug at the end due some script
 
DoomZero
Rating - 9
Textures suport (added in main textures.pk3)
 
NERVE (no rest 4...)
Rating - 9
 
DRN
Rating - 7
Comments - Dificult, short maps but vanilla
some difficult Puzzles
 

Dark Encounters Rated by: Xim
Rating - 9
Textures support
 

Going Down Rated by: Xim
Rating - 9
Textures support
 

NJ Doom2 Rated by: Xim
Rating - 8
Textures support
 

Revolution! Rated by: Xim
Rating - 7
Problems - some texture problems, some decoration/props problems (Maps have Hanging-Keen replacement)
 

Dark Universe Rated by: Xim
Rating - 9
Textures support, features Dark Forces textures
Problems - Custom fonts conflict with each other

Edited July 18, 2023 by WARDUST

[WARDUST]

Ozonia
Rating - 9
Textures and scripts suport (added in custom wads textures folder)

BGComp
Rating - 10
No problems here

Edited May 20, 2022 by WARDUST

[WARDUST]

Doomkid's MEGA (8 maps)
Rating - 9
Textures and scripts suport (added in custom was textures folder)

 

Edited August 10, 2023 by WARDUST

[WARDUST]

Plutonia 2
Rating - 9
Dificult but really good
Problems - Can't reach the end. Never sure with thouse endings like doom2, in wich you need launch some rokets to the Boss Brain
(Edited: currently this boss is replaced with our mods)
https://www.doomworld.com/idgames/levels/doom2/megawads/pl2

Shotgun Simphony
Rating - 10
No problems here

 

Edited August 10, 2023 by WARDUST

[WARDUST]

Hellbound
Rating - 9
Dificult but really good
Problems - Some lag at the maps 29 and 30 (big ammount of enemies) but playable.
Textures and scripts suport (added in custom was textures folder)
https://www.doomworld.com/idgames/levels/doom2/Ports/megawads/hellbnd

Plutonia revisited
Rating - 9
Dificult but really good
No problems
https://www.doomworld.com/idgames/levels/doom2/Ports/megawads/prcp

Scythe
Rating - 8
Everything really fine before arriving to level 26,
when it turns into a heavy slaugher wad (with lag if you use SPIDERS)
https://www.doomworld.com/idgames/levels/doom2/megawads/scythe

Edited August 10, 2023 by WARDUST
Add more info

[cwise103]

Thank you Wardust awesome mod

[WARDUST]

MacheteRC1
Rating - 8
Everything really fine before arriving to level 26, more or less
when it turns into a heavy slaugher wad (like Scythe again, yes)
Also in some level, where you die in a teletransport, you can't pass the level. In that case, open the console ingame, and type: special 243
You will jump to the next level (thanks for asking @Deadwing, that's a great discover!)

Textures and scripts suport (added in custom wad textures folder)

 

Edited August 10, 2023 by WARDUST

[WARDUST]

Ultimate Doom in Name Only
Rating - 8
Really good design, intense fights, sometimes impossible with lot of Varons in small places (that means many elite troops with no cover on your side)

Link:

 

[WARDUST]

NostalDoom (EP1 replacer)
Rating - 9'5
Absolutely an Amazing one, just the ending superdifficult (maybe impossible without IDDQD)

 

Edited July 20, 2023 by WARDUST

[Bri0che]

On 7/19/2023 at 1:10 AM, WARDUST said:

NostalDoom
Rating - 9'5
Absolutely an Amazing one, just the ending superdifficult (maybe impossible without IDDQD)

 

 

Thank you sir, I'm happy you liked NostalDoom :)

I have released a beta E2 for a WIP Doom I megawad recently, but I think you already saw it since you liked the post, I hope you will also like this one if you play it ! I definitely think this is a step up from this

Edited July 20, 2023 by Bri0che

[WARDUST]

I will make here a copy paste @Bri0che, thouse were a high enjoy, really classic well designed maps, full of action! the only thing doesn't match with my mod are the endings. My replacers for Barons are really heavy and fight with so many of them it's mostly a suicide, so IDDQD on the last maps, but... to the fabourites! you can be glad with your maps man

Ex Aequo (EP2 replacer)
Rating - 9'5
Absolutely an Amazing one, just the ending superdifficult (maybe impossible without IDDQD)

Link

 

Edited July 20, 2023 by WARDUST

[WARDUST]

Arrokoth (EP1 replacer)
Rating - 9
A cool an intense Doom1 wad. Winning without tricks.

 

[WARDUST]

THEME-GAWAD (Doom2)
Rating - 7
Cool since map 20 more or less, after that we can encounter many monsters together that has a difficult match with the mod on.
Some puzzles can be impossible with the mod textures (1 or two)

 

Edited August 10, 2023 by WARDUST

[WARDUST]

JAMAL JONES TRILOGY
Ratings Ep1 - 9      Ep2 - 10     Ep3 - 5
Completely amazing episode 2! due the use of diferent enemies, it let me put all the stuff with spiders etc (special pk3 inside custom maps folder). Ep 3 it's superhard and imposible with the mod on (slorer maps) but the other Episodes are perfect!

 

[WARDUST]

ICHIMICHI (Doom2)
Rating - 9
I was unable to reach the end platform, but anything else was perfect.